We consider the optimal progressivity of earnings taxation and whether capital income. An example with a ushaped pattern of optimal marginal tax rates, american economic. This handbook chapter considers optimal labor income taxation, that is, the fair. It examines conditions for the marginal tax rate to be higher at a low skill level than at the high skill level with the same densityan. The ita defines seven categories of income that are subjected to taxation. According to the ita each person is taxable with hisher own income. His paper makes explicit the factors that affect the optimal shape of income tax rates. An income tax is a tax imposed on individuals or entities that varies with respective income or profits taxable income. Woods if you have to pick one book, economics in one lesson is absolutely the best one to choose. Optimal taxation of income and human capital and skill. This paper analyzes the problem of optimal taxation of top labour incomes.
Individual income tax rates and tax shares, 1998 approximately 93. Using the 1979 income concept, taxable returns showed total in. The standard theory of optimal taxation posits that a tax system should be chosen to maximize a social welfare function subject to a set of constraints. The optimal tax rate for capital income is negative kenneth l. European governments aim to raise labour supply, cut unemployment and, at the same time, maintain social cohesion. The ita does not know a joint taxation of married couples or households. The book, income tax act provides the readers with elementary and advanced aspects of the income tax act. Using the mirrlees optimal income tax model with quasilinear preferences, the paper examines conditions for marginal tax rates to be rising at high income levels and declining in an interval containing the modal skill. Mirrlees nonlinear income tax model callsforprogressivenonlinear taxation of income. Henrik jacobsen kleven london school of economics lecture.
The divergence between book income and tax income mihir a. Kaplow 1998, whose analysis is closely related to our own approach, obtains a similar result. The optimal tax rate for capital income is negative nber. Mirrlees 1971, an exploration in the theory of optimum income taxation 22. Comprehensive description in gruber undergrad textbook. A number of arguments relating to concerns for efficiency and equity may be found in the literature supporting the taxation of capital income, including 1 corletthague motives, 2 increases in consumption inequality over the life cycle, 3 heterogeneous preferences, 4 correlation between returns on savings and ability, 5 incomplete or. Income tax generally is computed as the product of a tax rate times taxable income. An annotated bibliography of tax compliance and tax. Using elasticities to derive optimal income tax rates.
Optimal taxation in the presence of incomedependent relative. Discussing optimal accuracy and complexity for a given tax rate, kaplow notes that a more accurate income tax improves the resulting distribution of income p. Shouldwe have a mixof both, or onlyone of them, inorder to maximize social welfare. Although personal incomes were occasionally taxed in medieval italian cities, the income tax is essentially a modern form of taxation. A synthesis by robin boadway, queens university, canada motohiro sato, hitotsubashi university, japan january, 2012 abstract we study optimal nonlinear income taxation when earnings can di. This publication is the third edition of the condensed version of another oecd publication entitled model tax convention on income and on. Optimal taxation of income and human capital and skillbiased. Moreover, for a class of widely used preferences, consumption taxes are zero in the limit as well. For technical convenience, it is frequently assumed that income is continuous and in. However, in this literature, nonemployment, if any, is synonymous with nonparticipation. In the standard optimal income taxation problem, tax payments depend only on each consumers own actions.
Papers given at the 2006 irs research conference, statistics of income division, internal revenue service, department of the treasury, washington dc, pp. Lassers small business taxes 2015, the most trusted name in tax guidance helps small business owners maximize their bottom line. Optimal tax theory or the theory of optimal taxation is the study of designing and implementing a tax that maximises a social welfare function subject to economic constraints. In addition, by concentrating on the case where there is a zero income derivative of labor supply, the intuition behind the firstorder condition becomes clearer. Key simplification is the lack of income effects diamond, 1998. On the optimal taxation of capital income sciencedirect. A few general principles none the less gained the status of received. Several previous papers have studied problems of optimal income taxation and their relation to education decisions. Optimal progressive labor income taxation and education. I introduction since the seminal paper ofmirrlees1971, the optimal income tax literature provides formulas describing the optimal tax schedule. Sep, 2007 european governments aim to raise labour supply, cut unemployment and, at the same time, maintain social cohesion.
This result was theoretically established by diamond 1998 and. Optimal income taxation with multidimensional taxpayer types. An important strand of the literature on optimal taxation in dynamic economies concerns the proposition that the income tax rate on income from capital should be zero. Economics in one lesson, henry hazlitt meltdown, thomas e. Eliminate confusion, maximize deductions, reduce payments, and conquer your small business taxes with ease in j. Chelin suy july 31, 2006z abstract beginning with mirrlees, the optimal taxation literature has generally focused on economies where individuals are di. A special attention is given to one of the effects. This rearrangement leads to a different way of approaching the combinations of assumptions that will sign the change in marginal tax rates with income level.
Public economics we examine the problem of optimal taxation in a dynamic economy with imperfectly competitive markets. The first important income tax was levied in great britain from 1799 to 1816 in order to raise funds for the napoleonic wars. Using the mirrlees optimal income tax model with quasilinear. Optimal progressive labor income taxation and education subsidies when education decisions and intergenerational transfers are endogenous by dirk krueger and alexander ludwig. The social welfare function used is typically a function of individuals utilities, most commonly some form of utilitarian function, so the tax system is chosen to. Indeed, much of the recent concern over tax shelters reflects the use of treasury data to construct comparisons between tax income and book income as reported in schedule ml. The literature on optimal taxation typically treats the social planner as a utilitarian. Mirrlees 1971, optimal taxation and public production ii. Optimal income taxation sciences po department of economics.
Tax incidence and the welfare costs of taxation hindricks and myles, chapter 14. Agell, jonas and persson, mats 1990, tax arbitrage and the redistributive properties of progressive income taxation, economics letters, vol. For example, the financial times september 11, 1995 p. Optimal income taxation when asset taxation is limited. Income vs commodity taxation we have seen two models. Lipsey 2007, \reections on the general theory of second best at its golden jubilee, inter national tax and public finance, 14, 349364.
We study optimal nonlinear income taxation when earnings can differ because of both ability and luck, so the income tax has both a redistributive role and an insurance role. Taxation rates may vary by type or characteristics of the taxpayer. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first paper that explores optimal income taxation in a framework where assets are nonobservable. This book was written after the changes made by the finance act of 2011. We merge the canonical model of sbtc due to katz and murphy 1992 and acemoglu and autor 2011 with the standard mirrlees 1971 model of optimal nonlinear income taxation. Condensed version has been superceded by more recent editions. In a broad class of models, optimal taxation problems have the characteristic that the government taxes at a high rate in the initial periods to build up a surplus capital income taxation 95. In section 3 we discuss how the expression for optimal educationdependent marginal tax rates compares to the seminal optimal tax formulas from diamond 1998 and saez2001withexogenoushumancapital. Guide for taxation of income of researchers in austria.
Optimal nonlinear income taxation with costly tax avoidance borys grochulski t he central idea behind an important branch of modern public. Atkinson 1995,diamond 1998,piketty 1997,saez 2001 showed that the optimal. On the optimality of optimal income taxation request pdf. A substantial literature on optimal redistribution in the absence of uncertainty has evolved since mirrlees original contribution. Optimal income taxation with endogenous participation and. Since late 1990s, diamond aer98, piketty 97, saez restud 01 have. Optimal nonlinear income taxation with costly tax avoidance. Using the mirrlees optimal income tax model with quasilinear preferences, the paper. Optimal taxation in theory and practice 060109 final. We show that in models in which labor services are supplied jointly with human capital, the chamley and judd result on zero capital income taxation in the limit extends to labor taxes as long as accumulation technologies are constant returns to scale. Diamond 1998 reopened the debate on the optimal shape of income tax by showing an example of optimal increasing marginal tax rates schedule. Weinzierl 2011 examines partial tax reforms to agedependent labor income taxation, and shows that there are small welfare losses from implementing not full optimal historydependent income taxation, but agedependent income taxation. Buy incometax act book online at low prices in india.
Optimal income taxation with multidimensional taxpayer types kenneth l. Optimal taxation, multidimensional screening problems, tax perturbation, allocation perturbation, suf. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. Optimal agedependent income taxation in a dynamic extensive. Taxes pearsons federal taxation 2019 individuals 32nd edition jul 16 2018. Recent work on dynamic mirrleesian economies analyzes optimal income taxes when assets are observabletaxable without frictions. The ideas of james mirrlees, 19362018 vox, cepr policy portal. Yet, economists have stressed the tradeoff between these objectives. Desai harvard business school and nber executive summary this paper examines the evolution of the corporate profit base and the relationship between book income and tax income for u. One strand of inquiry has worked under the assumption of exante homogeneity and risky human capital.
541 791 286 55 818 1180 354 961 322 1366 1012 1138 1556 238 1636 466 826 684 1005 1267 1559 744 73 75 1031 102 937 324 428 1117 59 1383 781